Sign in Join
  • Home
  • Space
    • Aero Space
    • Analysis
    • Blog
    • ISRO
    • ISS
    • Launch Pad
    • Mars
    • Space Scopes
    • Tech
    • Chip Tech
  • Defense
    • BrahMos
    • INDIA & RUSSIA
    • INDIA VS PAKISTAN
    • Missile defense
  • Quora
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Loganspace Tamil
Sign in
Welcome!Log into your account
Forgot your password?
Create an account
Privacy Policy
Sign up
Welcome!Register for an account
A password will be e-mailed to you.
Privacy Policy
Password recovery
Recover your password
Search
Saturday, January 28, 2023
  • Sign in / Join
Sign in
Welcome! Log into your account
Forgot your password? Get help
Create an account
Privacy Policy
Create an account
Welcome! Register for an account
A password will be e-mailed to you.
Privacy Policy
Password recovery
Recover your password
A password will be e-mailed to you.
tamil.loganspace.com LoganSpace.com
Google Ads
tamil.loganspace.com tamil.loganspace.com
  • Home
  • Space
    • AllAero SpaceAnalysisBlogISROISSLaunch PadMarsSpace ScopesTechChip Tech
      [NEWS] Max-Q: This week in space – Loganspace
      News

      [NEWS] Max-Q: This week in space – Loganspace

      [Science] Weird repeating signals from deep space may be created by starquakes – AI
      science

      [Science] Weird repeating signals from deep space may be created by…

      [NEWS] Relativity, a new star in the space race, raises $160 million for its 3-D printed rockets – Loganspace
      3D

      [NEWS] Relativity, a new star in the space race, raises $160…

      [NEWS] Relativity Space signs its the satellite transportation company Momentus as its first customer – Loganspace
      News

      [NEWS] Relativity Space signs its the satellite transportation company Momentus as…

  • Defense
    • AllBrahMosINDIA & RUSSIAINDIA VS PAKISTANMissile defense
      [NEWS] In latest $10B JEDI contract twist, Defense Secretary recuses himself – Loganspace
      Defense

      [NEWS] In latest $10B JEDI contract twist, Defense Secretary recuses himself…

      [NEWS] Exclusive: As North Korea expands arsenal, Japan’s missile defense shield faces unforeseen costs – sources – Loganspace AI
      Defense

      [NEWS] Exclusive: As North Korea expands arsenal, Japan’s missile defense shield…

      [NEWS] China destabilizing Indo-Pacific: U.S. Defense Secretary – Loganspace AI
      CHINA

      [NEWS] China destabilizing Indo-Pacific: U.S. Defense Secretary – Loganspace AI

      [NEWS] U.S. Defense Secretary says he favors placing missiles in Asia – Loganspace AI
      Defense

      [NEWS] U.S. Defense Secretary says he favors placing missiles in Asia…

  • Quora
    • Defense

      Why did US 7th fleet turn back when confronted by the…

      Analysis

      How did an obsolete Surface-to-air missile like the Soviet SA-3 manage…

      Defense

      How do you see Pakistan testing Ababeel MIRV missile? is it…

      Defense

      Military Intelligence Officer: Imagination vs Real Responsibilities!?

      Defense

      loganspace(my) views on one day ban on NDTV?

  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Loganspace Tamil
Home Space Analysis How did an obsolete Surface-to-air missile like the Soviet SA-3 manage to...
  • Space
  • Analysis
  • Defense
  • Missile defense
  • Quora

How did an obsolete Surface-to-air missile like the Soviet SA-3 manage to shoot down the most advanced US stealth aircraft like the F117 nighthawk?

As was brought out by other answers, it was a combination of factors, of which luck definitely wasn’t a part, which resulted in the shooting down of the ill fated F-117 at the hands of the 3rd Battalion of the 250th Air Defence Brigade of the Yugoslav Army commanded by the resourceful and competent Col Zoltan Dani.

By
Logan
-
February 12, 2017
0
Facebook
Twitter
Pinterest
WhatsApp

    I would however like to provide a more ‘technical’ answer focusing on the equipment fielded by Col Dani i.e., the S-125 ‘Neva’ Surface to Air Missile System and modifications to the same, like the Soviet SA-3

    The missile like the Soviet SA-3 system utilises three primary radar systems
    1. The P-15 M2 ‘Squat Eye’ C-Band Target Acquisition Radar.
    2. The SNR-125 ‘Low Blow’ I/D Band Tracking,Guidance and Fire Control Radar.
    3. The PRV-11 ‘SideNet’ E – Band Height Finding Radar.
    The F-117 was the first operational stealth fighter and the Soviet engineers quickly turned their attention towards Very Low Observability or VLO aircraft, developing radar systems operating in the lower bands such as VHF – UHF and upto L Band.

    Read more about: Why can’t a pilot simply change course or turn sharply to evade an incoming missile?

    Most stealth design features are intended to scatter incoming radar waves aka illumination in a controlled fashion, evidenced by the use of edge alignment, faceting and other geometrical shaping features, supplemented by the use of absorbent materials as demonstrated in the design of the F-117 Nighthawk.
    All of these techniques are intended to defeat radars operating in the geometrical optics and less frequently, resonance zones of scattering.

    Read more about: India to build BrahMos 3 for Russia

    The precondition for this to work is that the wavelength be much shorter than the cardinal dimensions of the shaping feature of interest i.e., the specially designed fuselage or wings.

    The Soviet approach has been to invest in the further development of low band radars, especially operating in the VHF band. The physics of radar scattering depend to a large extent on the size of the radar wavelength vs the physical size of the target.

    In the Raleigh scattering regime, the wavelength is similar or greater in magnitude to the physical size of the target, and the magnitude of the reflection is essentially proportional to the physical size of the target.
    As the wavelength is reduced, the resonant region is entered, where the wavelength is comparable in size to key shaping features on the target, and the magnitude of the reflection fluctuates strongly with wavelength and aspect. Finally, in the optical scattering regime, target shaping can be used to precisely control the magnitude and direction of reflections.
    The high effectiveness of stealth designs against decimetric and centimetric band radars reflects the reality that for most aircraft sizes, these wavelengths are a tenth to a hundredth of the size of key shaping features.
    This explains the Soviet affinity towards low band radars to detect VLO aircraft.

    Low band radars are not however the silver bullets to defeat VLO aircraft as they are made out to be.

    Their angular accuracy is notoriously poor, and the required antenna size results in ungainly systems which are usually slow to deploy and stow, even if designed from the outset for mobility.

    The size and high power emissions of these radars, coupled with limited mobility, makes them much easier to detect and destroy than typical mobile systems operating in the decimetric and centimetric bands, which can relocate rapidly after a missile shot.

    Despite these drawbacks, the older Russian low band radars still provide a valuable early warning capability, and enable cueing of other sensors and platforms, which is of most importance here.

    Read more about: How is it possible that Pakistan authorities didn’t know of the surgical strike until India made an official statement? part – II

    Which is exactly what happened that night. With the NATO communications decrypted successfully and missile batteries placed at strategic points the Yugoslavs were already a step ahead.

    The Squat Eye low band tracking radars were modified to large extent by use of solid state electronics effectively digitising their operation.

    Moreover speculation has it that modern Digital Moving Target Indicator (DMTI) or digital pulse Doppler techniques were employed, possibly using Space Time Adaptive Processing (STAP), exploiting the high performance of COTS computing technology, readily available in the open market and easy to ruggedised for a semi-mobile application of this kind.

    That night when the F-117 opened its bomb bay doors for munitions release, the slight change/increase in the RCS was picked up by the Squat Eye tracking radar at a distance of 50–60 Kms.

    Now as discussed earlier the angular accuracy wasn’t that great for these low band tracking radars, but it was enough to cue and activate the accompanying fire control/engagement radar.

    Enter the SNR-125 LowBlow Engagement Radar

    SNR-125 uses a pair of fixed scanned trough antennas to generate flapping fan shaped beams, but the design is inherently Scan ON Receive Only or SORO with a separate transmit antenna mounted between the characteristic chevron arrangement of trough antennas. Optical adjunct tracking using the 9Sh33A Karat 2 television telescope has been installed on later variants probably used by missile battery in question here. The antenna at the top of the turret is used for the low power missile FMCW uplink channels.

    The Low Blow is designed to acquire targets using only bearing and range inputs from an external 2D acquisition radar in this case the Squat Eye.

    When acquiring a target, the Low Blow radar head is rotated to the target bearing and the UV-10 antenna scanning feed engaged to produce a 1° wide pencil beam swept in elevation.

    Once the target is acquired the Low Blow is switched into tracking mode, using the UV-10 antenna to transmit, the UV-10 to receive for ranging, and the scanning UV-11 chevron receive antennas for angle tracking.

    The radar head is mechanically steered in azimuth and elevation to maintain track.

    The Low Blow provides manual tracking, automatic tracking and television angle tracking modes. The system provides five missile guidance control laws, TT (CLOS), PS, MV (LoAlt), K (surface target attack) and DKM (ballistic). Three missile uplink signals are employed, K1 and K2 for pitch/yaw steering, and K3 for fuse control.

    The Russian doctrine in the presence of heavy jamming and anti radiation missiles was often to cease emitting and use the scanning receiver to effect angle tracking of the jammer, acquire the target with the TV telescope, and perform a range unknown missile shot against the target/jammer in CLOS mode.

    Which is what happened here as soon as the target was tracked by the Squat Eye the Low Blow swung into action and several range unknown missile shots were fired.

    The missile fuses were calibrated prior to account for the lack of accuracy and un known range. All of this supposedly happened in 17 secs to prevent NATO counter radiation action.

    The rest as they say is history as per Wikipedia:

    The F-117, callsign “Vega-31“, was being flown by Lt. Col. Dale Zelko, an Operation Desert Storm veteran. He observed the two missiles punch through the low cloud cover and head straight for his aircraft.

    The first passed over him, close enough to cause buffeting, but did not detonate. The second missile detonated, causing significant damage to the aircraft and causing it to tumble, out of control.The explosion was large enough to be seen from a KC-135 Stratotanker, flying over Bosnia.

    Share this:

    • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
    • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
    • Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window)
    • Click to share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window)
    • Click to share on Skype (Opens in new window)
    • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
    • Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window)
    • Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window)
    • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window)
    • More
    • Click to print (Opens in new window)
    • Click to share on Telegram (Opens in new window)
    • Click to share on Pocket (Opens in new window)

    Related

    • TAGS
    • AI
    • BrahMos
    • eso
    • event
    • india
    • NATO
    • pak
    • pakistan
    • Pakistan authorities didn't know of the surgical strike
    • russia vs us
    • Soviet SA-3
    • space
    • Tech
    • technology
    • TV
    Facebook
    Twitter
    Pinterest
    WhatsApp
      Previous articleHow do you see Pakistan testing Ababeel MIRV missile? is it Repainted Chinese Cracks?
      Next articleWhy did US 7th fleet turn back when confronted by the Soviet Navy in the 1971 India-Pakistan war? Americans boast about being the best in the world.
      Logan
      https://www.loganspace.com/
      hi, I am Logan from Bangalore. In 2014, I started contributing to Loganspace Media Group, and life has just gotten better from there. Co-Founder & Chief Editor - Logan from Loganspace.com

      RELATED ARTICLESMORE FROM AUTHOR

      [NEWS] In latest $10B JEDI contract twist, Defense Secretary recuses himself – Loganspace
      Defense

      [NEWS] In latest $10B JEDI contract twist, Defense Secretary recuses himself – Loganspace

      [NEWS] Exclusive: As North Korea expands arsenal, Japan’s missile defense shield faces unforeseen costs – sources – Loganspace AI
      Defense

      [NEWS] Exclusive: As North Korea expands arsenal, Japan’s missile defense shield faces unforeseen costs – sources – Loganspace AI

      [NEWS] China destabilizing Indo-Pacific: U.S. Defense Secretary – Loganspace AI
      CHINA

      [NEWS] China destabilizing Indo-Pacific: U.S. Defense Secretary – Loganspace AI

      [NEWS] U.S. Defense Secretary says he favors placing missiles in Asia – Loganspace AI
      Defense

      [NEWS] U.S. Defense Secretary says he favors placing missiles in Asia – Loganspace AI

      [NEWS] Turkish defense firms set to lose billions after F-35 removal – Loganspace AI
      Defense

      [NEWS] Turkish defense firms set to lose billions after F-35 removal – Loganspace AI

      [NEWS] Turkey says defense firms face temporary losses after F-35 removal – Loganspace AI
      Defense

      [NEWS] Turkey says defense firms face temporary losses after F-35 removal – Loganspace AI

      You must log in to post a comment.

      Trending Now

      [Science] Tree stumps that should be dead can be kept alive by nearby trees – AI

      [NEWS #Alert] Who are the biggest bullshitters?! – #Loganspace AI

      [NEWS] Argentina’s Macri shelves sales taxes as he seeks to cut left’s lead – Loganspace AI

      [NEWS] How to get people to open your emails – Loganspace

      [NEWS] U.S. rapper A$AP Rocky pleads not guilty in Stockholm assault case – Loganspace AI

      Textile Industries are Dying ? | What is Happening in Textile Sectors | Anand Srinivasan
      COVID-19

      Textile Industries are Dying? | What is Happening in Textile Sectors | Anand Srinivasan

      Logan - April 23, 2021
      Editor's choice

      India needs vaccines now, but this Rs 904-crore PSU in Tamil Nadu has been idle for 9 years

      GJ832
      Analysis

      Earth-like planet GJ832 in star system only 16 light years away

      panda ant
      Analysis

      Walking Fish, panda ant … fairy animals that have not yet seen!

      DON'T MISS

      • All
      • Featured
      • All time popular
      More

        Popular

        • All
        • Featured
        • All time popular
        More
          Textile Industries are Dying ? | What is Happening in Textile Sectors | Anand Srinivasan
          COVID-19

          Textile Industries are Dying? | What is Happening in Textile Sectors...

          Logan - April 23, 2021 0
          Today i wanted to talk about the troubles in the MSME and SME sector since I'm from Tamil Nadu I would like to talk...
          Editor's choice

          India needs vaccines now, but this Rs 904-crore PSU in Tamil...

          Logan - April 20, 2021 0
          Chengalpattu/New Delhi: With the second wave of Covid-19 sweeping India and new strains of the SARS-CoV-2 pathogen threatening more harm, the clamor for vaccines...
          [Science] Google hits back at IBM’s quantum supremacy challenge – AI

          [Science] Google hits back at IBM’s quantum supremacy challenge – AI

          October 24, 2019
          [NEWS] Legged lunar rover startup Spacebit taps Latin American partners for Moon mission – Loganspace

          [NEWS] Legged lunar rover startup Spacebit taps Latin American partners for...

          October 24, 2019
          [NEWS] Vendr, already profitable, raises $2M to replace your enterprise sales team – Loganspace

          [NEWS] Vendr, already profitable, raises $2M to replace your enterprise sales...

          October 24, 2019
          [Science] Vaccines have helped us eradicate another strain of wild polio virus – AI

          [Science] Vaccines have helped us eradicate another strain of wild polio...

          October 24, 2019

          Defense

          Defense

          India retaliates, up to 20 killed on Pak side

          Defense

          NATO watching Crimea tensions with ‘concern’

          Defense

          India’s Defenсe Acquisition Council (DAC) clears deal on purchase of Russian...

          TECH AND GADGETS

          • All
          • Featured
          • All time popular
          More
            others

            25 Years After Neptune: Reflections on Voyager

            Logan - August 27, 2014 0
            Neptune is in view. It is the middle of the night and everything is happening fast at NASA's Jet Propulsion Laboratory...
            Scientists at TUM research on energy storage technologies.. new ways to produce lithium-ion-batteries. Image courtesy Heddergott and TUM.

            Energy storage technologies: Asian inventions Analysis

            August 22, 2014
            [NEWS] Tencent promises its technology will ‘do good’ – Loganspace

            [NEWS] Tencent promises its technology will ‘do good’ – Loganspace

            May 7, 2019

            Japan puts new weather satellite into space

            October 8, 2014

            Scottish independence may force UK nuclear deterrent rethink

            September 13, 2014
            - Advertisement -
            [vc_facebook][vc_tweetmeme type=”follow” follow_user=”loganspace3″ show_followers_count=”true” large_button=”true” disable_tailoring=”true”]

            STAY CONNECTED

            120FansLike
            78,581FollowersFollow
            116FollowersFollow
            236SubscribersSubscribe
            - Advertisement -

            MAKE IT MODERN

            [NEWS #Alert] Donald Trump launches his re-election campaign! – #Loganspace AI
            News

            [NEWS #Alert] Donald Trump launches his re-election campaign! – #Loganspace AI

            Defense

            China rolls out export trainer/fighter aircraft:

            Loganspace Logo
            INDIA

            Hope to sign BrahMos mini agreement by year-end: Sudhir Kumar Mishra

            LATEST REVIEWS

            [NEWS] Sri Lanka detains Syrian for questioning over attacks: sources – Loganspace AI
            News

            [NEWS] Sri Lanka detains Syrian for questioning over attacks: sources –...

            Logan - April 23, 2019 0
            COLOMBO (Reuters) - Sri Lankan police are holding a Syrian national in custody for questioning over the Easter Sunday attacks on churches and hotels, three government and military sources told Reuters on Tuesday. “The terrorist investigation division of the police arrested a Syrian national following the attacks for interrogation,” a source said. Two other officials…
            Loganspace Logo

            Sanctions against Moscow to boost Indian businesses in Russia – Sammy...

            August 27, 2014
            [NEWS] Buy now, pay later and save on passes to Disrupt San Francisco 2019 – Loganspace

            [NEWS] Buy now, pay later and save on passes to Disrupt...

            April 18, 2019
            - Advertisement -

            Share this:

            • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
            • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
            • Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window)
            • Click to share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window)
            • Click to share on Skype (Opens in new window)
            • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
            • Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window)
            • Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window)
            • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window)
            • More
            • Click to print (Opens in new window)
            • Click to share on Telegram (Opens in new window)
            • Click to share on Pocket (Opens in new window)

            Related

            MORE STORIES
            Textile Industries are Dying ? | What is Happening in Textile Sectors | Anand Srinivasan

            Textile Industries are Dying? | What is Happening in Textile Sectors...

            April 23, 2021

            India needs vaccines now, but this Rs 904-crore PSU in Tamil...

            April 20, 2021
            [Science] Google hits back at IBM’s quantum supremacy challenge – AI

            [Science] Google hits back at IBM’s quantum supremacy challenge – AI

            October 24, 2019